Lebanese general killed

Snapped Shot informs us

Wow, so yesterday’s concussion grenade was not anything major, but it was followed up by a major car bombing in a different part of town, an event that took the life of one of Lebanon’s most fiercely anti-Syrian generals. Was the first attack intended to distract the Lebanese security forces, and to provide an opening for the second attack?


The Washington Post
(with no sense of irony) gives play to some of the hypocrisy here:

Asked about the culprit, shop owner Rafael shrugged his shoulders, a gesture conveying the anonymity of those behind the assassinations that have become part of the country’s political calculus. Government supporters blamed Syria, as they have in bombings that targeted eight prominent opponents of Syria in the past two years. Syria denied any role and suggested that Israel or its allies had a hand in the attack.Government opponents, led by the Shiite Muslim movement Hezbollah, denounced the attack, calling Hajj’s death “a great national loss.” One of their Christian allies, former general Michel Aoun, said Hajj had been his candidate to assume leadership of the army if parliament elected the present commander, Gen. Michel Suleiman, as president. While government opponents and supporters have agreed in principle on Suleiman succeeding former president Emile Lahoud, who stepped down Nov. 23 at the end of his term, negotiations have stalled over a comprehensive deal to resolve the crisis, the country’s worst since the 1975-90 civil war.

Israel did it and Hezbollah denounced it. Right.

The New York Times deserves credit for leaving Israel out of the story, and pointing to an ominous statement by a Syrian politician.

Some leading anti-Syrian politicians blamed Damascus for the killing, as they have for a series of political assassinations during the past three years. They pointed to comments made Tuesday by the Syrian vice president, Farouq Sharaa, who said that Syria’s friends in Lebanon were stronger than ever and that “no one in Lebanon, even with foreign support, can win the battle against Syria.”

The Times has followed up the reporting with news of a crackdown in Syria.

The arrests followed Syria’s participation in the Middle East peace forum at Annapolis, Md., which was seen in the region as a coup for Syria and a sign of a thaw in relations between Mr. Assad and the White House.Emboldened by a sense that Syria’s tough anti-American policies have paid dividends, human rights advocates say, the authorities have turned to closing the last channels of public debate.

“This goes back to what we’ve always seen as a problem, that the opening with the West has never been contingent on Syria improving its human rights records,” Nadim Houry, who tracks Syria for Human Rights Watch, said. “It’s contingent on Syria cooperating on Lebanon, Iraq and the peace process.”

Hmm, sense from a member of Human Rights Watch. And sentiments that have been expressed by a number of bloggers, that Annapolis has strengthened Bashar Assad’s hand.

Similarly Barry Rubin writes

Claims made often verge on the pitiful. For example, dozens of observers insisted that Syria’s presence at the Annapolis summit showed that it was splitting away from Iran, which opposed the meeting. They forget that Syria participated in a nine-year-long peace process that Iran opposed–including direct negotiations with Israel–without damaging in the slightest the Iran-Syria axis.Second, this kind of talk destroys years of effort to isolate and pressure Syria. The tough strategy is not some silly stubborn refusal to chat with Damascus but designed to deter the regime from adventurism, shore up Arab states’ opposition to it, and encourage Lebanese forces battling against again becoming a puppet of the dictator next door.

And it looks like the effort to get Syria to Annapolis has emboldened Assad rather than engaging him.

JoshuaPundit sees even larger forces at play:

This is a clear signal that Iran and Syria are not going to be content with just Suleiman in the presidency. They want control of the Lebanese military, and they want anti-Syrian PM Fuad Siniora out as well, and in fairly short order, with Hezbollah, Amal and the pro-Syrian factions assuming total control of Lebanon.This will ensure that Lebanon comes under the control of Syria and Iran, and that the UN tribunal implicating members of Basher Assad’s family and other top Syrian political figures in the 2005 assassination of ex-PM Rafiq Hariri goes nowhere.

Like Israel, Lebanon’s democracy is the chief casualty of the new `understanding’ engineered by the Saudis between Iran and the Bush Administration

Seraphic Secret worries about the implications for Israel.

Israel is now being surrounded and strangled in a terrorist vice: Gaza, Lebanon; now the Israeli government talks of dividing Jerusalem and turning Judea and Samaria over to the Arabs, which means a deadly encirclement by short-range weapons—snipers and mortars.

Outrageously Joshua Landis defends Syria. Michael Young on the other hand explains what Syria’s been up to.

Creating a vacuum is not a strategy; it is a tactic designed to bring someone to power on Syria’s terms. Damascus wants exclusivity in the next Lebanese president, but without its armed forces in the country to impose this, a new officeholder might prove too independent. That’s why we should doubt Sharaa when he says, as he did on Tuesday, that Syria does not intend to return to Lebanon “militarily or in a security capacity.” But it’s also why, in believing that they cannot dominate the Lebanese without an armed presence, the Syrians might be overreaching. The Syrian move into Lebanon in 1976 required a regional and international consensus, as well as an Israeli green light, and was formalized by the Arab League. That’s unlikely to happen again today. In forcing the issue, doesn’t the Assad regime risk provoking a powerful local, regional and international backlash that might ultimately scuttle its plans?

(Both via the The POMED Wire)

Syria believes it can act with impunity. Someone needs the will and the means to exact a price from Syria for its latest adventurism or the situation will continue to deteriorate.

Crossposted on Soccer Dad.

Posted in Israel | 1 Comment

E-yenta

Rabbi Weber wants to encourage Jews to marry Jews.

Rabbi Donald Weber is far from the first rabbi to call for single Jews in his congregation to marry other Jews.Such pulpit calls have become commonplace in an age of high Jewish intermarriage rates and fears the Jewish population will fall sharply in coming generations. But the Reform rabbi’s recent appeal came with a novel twist.

Six weeks ago, in his Yom Kippur sermon at Temple Rodeph Torah, Weber offered to personally pay for six-month memberships to JDate, the popular Jewish online dating service, for any singles in the congregation who asked.

What concerned Rabbi Weber was this:

The need is there, he said, be cause the American Jewish population has declined in recent decades, with about half of American Jews marrying outside the religion, according to widely reported national surveys. Weber punctuated his sermon by citing a recent study from the Hebrew Union College Jewish Institute of Religion indicating that fewer than 10% of grandchildren of intermarried parents identify as Jews.

Despite the fact that this puts Rabbi Weber in opposition to some of his congregants – Reform Temples accept non-Jewish spouses as full members – he is persisting.

I’m impressed.

(h/t Mrs. Soccer Dad)

Crossposted at Soccer Dad.

Posted in Israel, Jews | 3 Comments

Palestinian terrorists aiming for farmers now

Not content with trying to murder schoolchildren with “crude, homemade rockets,” the Palestinian thugs are trying to kill farmers in the field now.

These are the attacks you never read about in the AP or Reuters reports. All you read about there are the Israeli responses to trying to keep their people from being murdered.

Palestinian terrorists in the Gaza Strip launched three Kassam rockets into Israel Thursday morning, causing no casualties or damages.

Meanwhile, in two separate incidents near the Gaza security fence, gunmen opened fire at farmers working in their fields and at IDF bulldozers engaged in engineering work. There were no casualties in either incident.

Say, people who say that the Palestinians are only fighting against “the occupation,” kindly tell me which occupation counts farmers working in their fields. Oh, that’s right. The one that says all of Israel is Muslim land, which is, coincidentally, what the Hamas charter says. And oh yeah, a group that wants the UN to rescind the partition of Israel and insists that Israel should not exist. That kind of organization, and those kind of people, are the ones who would murder farmers in the field, and children in their beds.

The one that people say Israel should talk to. Because talking to an organization that wants you dead, that totally works.

Posted in Israel | 5 Comments

North Korea, Iran, Syria: Axis of Evil

The new Axis of Evil carries on. The Dear Leader isn’t satisfied with just starving and murdering his own people. He’s working on making sure he helps murder Israelis as well. This is on top of supplying Syria with nukes.

North Korea may have given arms to Lebanon’s Hizbullah and Sri Lanka’s Tamil Tigers, according to a report compiled for Congress that could complicate US plans to drop Pyongyang from its terrorism blacklist.

The report obtained on Wednesday by Reuters was written by the Congressional Research Service (CRS), which provides independent analysis to Congress, and cited “reputable sources” as saying Pyongyang had given arms and possibly training to the militant groups, which Washington regards as “terrorist” organizations.

North Korea, Syria, Iran.

It said that in September 2006, Paris Intelligence Online, a French Internet publication that specializes in political and economic intelligence, had published details of an extensive North Korean program to give arms and training to Hizbullah.

[…] The French publication said the program began in the 1980s with visits by Hizbullah members to North Korea for training and expanded after 2000 with the dispatch of North Koreans to Lebanon to train Hizbullah members how to build underground bunkers to store arms, food and medical facilities.

It said this training “significantly improved Hizbullah’s ability to fight the Israelis” during the 2006 war.

The CRS document also cited a report by a prominent South Korean academic, Moon Chung-in, that the Mossad Israeli intelligence agency believed that “vital missile components” used by Hizbullah against Israel came from North Korea.

The bad news is that this training worked. The good news is that Israel’s enemies are still fighting the last war, while Israel is planning and working towards the next one.

In a possible war with Syria, he said, the army would not combat rocket attacks on Israel’s home front as it had during the war in Lebanon. “So long as there are rockets falling on homes in Israel – we can not win the war. We will not fight as the army has in the past. We will not only operate against the rocket launchers themselves but also create a situation where the other side’s desire to launch these attacks sufferers, the price for these attacks will be steep – and the enemy will have to decide whether it can keep fighting.

“In a playground like Syria, we have the capability to strike them,” said Ashkenazi.

In every generation, they rise against us. In some generations, more than others.

Posted in Israel, World | Comments Off on North Korea, Iran, Syria: Axis of Evil

Nose, face, slice

Earlier this week, the UN passed a resolution introduced by Israel.

In a historic first, a committee of the United Nations General Assembly adopted an Israeli-initiated resolution on working matters. The resolution deals with agricultural technology for development, a relatively apolitical matter. But even such apolitical issues have not managed to squeeze past Arab opposition in the past. Supported by 118 countries, the resolution was introduced early this year.

But there’s a catch.

There were 29 abstentions, mostly from Arab countries. It is all but certain to be formally adopted by the General Assembly soon.

This sort of insult doesn’t seem to much interest the New York Times, but the Jerusalem Post observed:

On Tuesday, Israel’s Ambassador to the United Nations Dan Gillerman lauded the passage of an Israeli-drafted resolution in a UN committee for the first time ever. “For Israel, this is a very dramatic development and a historic day at the UN. This makes Israel a much more normal and acceptable member of the UN. One of our main aims is to not be a one issue country and to bring awareness of Israel’s excellence to the world,” Gillerman gushed. We hate to rain on this parade, but our own diplomats giving credence to claims that the UN is in any way treating Israel as “normal and acceptable” is like thanking a bully for slapping a new “kick me” sign on our backs.

More extensively the Post argues:

Even this “dramatic moment” was polluted by the incessant Arab campaign to delegitimize Israel. The utterly unobjectionable resolution, which urged member states to assist with agricultural development in developing countries, passed by a vote of 118 to 0, but with 29 abstentions and an even larger number registered “absent.” Most of the countries that could not bring themselves to vote for this banal resolution only because it was introduced by Israel were Arab or Muslim states, including many of those whose foreign ministers showed up in Annapolis, ostensibly to promote peace with Israel. Among these were Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Jordan. But the list of those not willing to stand with Israel even to promote development, largely in Africa, also included non-Muslim African states such as South Africa, Lesotho, Zambia, and Zimbabwe. Many African states did support the resolution, but many others either abstained or were absent. In short, while this “breakthrough” resolution could be cited to exemplify the isolation of the Arab bloc, it also dramatically demonstrates the refusal of this same bloc and the countries that blindly vote with it to remotely treat Israel as a nation like any other – namely a nation with the right to exist – let alone a peace-seeking democracy under terrorist attack.

Elder of Ziyon rightly characterizes this as another example of Misoziony.

OK, so it is not that the Arab nations – even the ones supposedly at peace with Israel – have anything against the resolution. They just cannot stand to agree with anything Israel says, no matter how innocuous. It is easier to abstain than to even give the appearance of being on the same side as the hated Zionists on any issue. This is beyond politics – this is just a seething hatred for anything that Israel does; this is misoziony. The very idea of agreeing with the Jewish state on anything sticks in the throats of the Arab world. For them, emotion trumps logic, and visceral hate makes real peace impossible.

Israel has an outreach program called Mashav and, yes, it aids Arab governments too through this program. The subject of the “historic” resolution was agricultural technology. Israel actually is doing something about spreading the relevant know how around the world. For example: Jordan

In cooperation with Jordan, MASHAV operates a demonstration farm in the Karak region for intensive sheep’s milk production and processing, introducing the advanced “Awassi” sheep to the country which provide approximately four times the milk yields of indigenous sheep. The project includes over 400 sheep, a milking parlor and state-of-the-art mini dairy for the production of yoghurts and cheeses. In addition, the project’s sheep have been used to upgrade local flocks through breeding activities.

Egypt

Israel actively cooperated with Egypt’s Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation on Egypt’s national program of land reclamation (the “Mubarak project”) aimed at resettling and training unemployed university graduates on desert lands along the Nile delta. Cooperation centered on on-site demonstration activities, including professional training programs and the establishment of an irrigation demonstration plot at the Maryut International Training Center in Nubariya, Egypt and short-and long-term consultancies. In the context of this program, over 5,000 Egyptians were trained both in Israel and in Egypt and many joint R&D projects were successfully launched.

Palestinian Authority

Over 775 Palestinians trained in Israel in the first three quarters of the year 2000. In particular, there was fruitful cooperation in the fields of Agriculture, Environment, and Civil Society with major projects being launched between Israeli and Palestinian Ministries, hospitals and utility services providers.

But that stopped.

Unfortunately, in September 2000, the Palestinian Authority issued a clear directive to all official Palestinian bodies and NGOs to suspend all cooperation with Israel. It is our hope that with advances in the political process, it will be possible to once again achieve the high level of cooperation which we once enjoyed.

Admittedly Israel hasn’t implemented a huge number of programs for the Arab world, but the programs do exist. And the small number is a function of Arab resistance not of Israeli willingness. In fact it’s ironic that in the case of the Palestinian that they spurn efforts to make them more independent and embrace those that seek to perpetuate their dependency.

Crossposted on Soccer Dad.

Posted in Israel | 2 Comments

Muslim man defends Jews on NYC subway

A Muslim man came to the defense of Jews under attack in the New York subway last Friday.

NEW YORK (CNN) — A Muslim man jumped to the aid of three Jewish subway riders after they were attacked by a group of young people who objected to one of the Jews saying “Happy Hanukkah,” a spokeswoman for the three said Wednesday.

Friday’s altercation on the Q train began when somebody yelled out “Merry Christmas,” to which rider Walter Adler responded, “Happy Hanukkah,” said Toba Hellerstein.

“Almost immediately, you see the look in this guy’s face like I’ve called his mother something,” Adler told CNN affiliate WABC.

Two women who were with a group of 10 rowdy people then began to verbally assault Adler’s companions with anti-Semitic language, Hellerstein said.

One member of the group allegedly yelled, “Oh, Hanukkah. That’s the day that the Jews killed Jesus,” she said.

When Adler tried to intercede, a male member of the group punched him, she said.

Another passenger, Hassan Askari — a Muslim student from Bangladesh — came to Adler’s aid, and the group began physically and verbally assaulting him, Hellerstein said.

Now this is the kind of story that gives me hope. Thank you, Hassan Askari. You’re a mensch

Posted in Anti-Semitism, Religion | 6 Comments

Stop complaining about the winter weather

Lynn got me to find this site, which has the sunrise and sunsets in Reykjavik, Iceland.

Sunrise tomorrow is 11:13 a.m. Sunset is 3:31 p.m.

Quitcherbitchin, people. Just think how much it would suck to be in Iceland right now.

Posted in Miscellaneous | 10 Comments

Israel is fighting the next war

I’ve been saying for some time now that the IDF has learned many lessons from the Lebanon war of 2006, and that Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria, and Iran have not.

Here’s what amounts to a throwaway graf at the end of an article about the Gaza rocket attacks that speaks volumes.

In a possible war with Syria, he said, the army would not combat rocket attacks on Israel’s home front as it had during the war in Lebanon. “So long as there are rockets falling on homes in Israel – we can not win the war. We will not fight as the army has in the past. We will not only operate against the rocket launchers themselves but also create a situation where the other side’s desire to launch these attacks sufferers, the price for these attacks will be steep – and the enemy will have to decide whether it can keep fighting.

“In a playground like Syria, we have the capability to strike them,” said Ashkenazi.

Something tells me that Baby Assad’s homes are high up on the list of places that will be bombed if Syria launches rockets toward Israel. But not just him. I’m quite sure the IDF has a list of targets to destroy should the Israeli homefront have to deal with a second barrage of rockets from an enemy.

Posted in Israel, Syria | 2 Comments

The wire services: Working for the Palestinians

Let’s look at the ledes on the various wire service articles about the current round of peace talks.

Earlier, Reuters:

Israel and Palestinians launch peace talks in discord
JERUSALEM (Reuters) – Palestinians said on Wednesday they had demanded a halt to Israeli plans to build on occupied land when negotiators launched peace talks aimed at reaching a deal on Palestinian statehood by the end of 2008.

No mention at all of the rocket attacks from Gaza, until about the thirteenth paragraph.

Later, Reuters:

Israel and Palestinians launch peace talks in discord
JERUSALEM (Reuters) – The first peace talks in seven years between Israel and the Palestinians opened in discord on Wednesday with the Palestinians demanding a halt to settlement building and Israel calling for a crackdown on militants.

You would think that perhaps, based on that change in the lede, that Reuters would identify the rocket barrage that wounded a girl in Sderot this morning, and put it high up in the article. You would be wrong. The mention of the rocket barrage has not moved from the thirteenth graf.

The AP has changed the lede somewhat, too. Earlier:

JERUSALEM (AP) – The first formal peace talks between Israelis and Palestinians in seven years got off to a rocky start Wednesday, with the Palestinians lambasting Israel for a new construction project planned in disputed east Jerusalem and Israel accusing the Palestinians of creating a “tense atmosphere.”

The Palestinians have said the planned construction in the Har Homa neighborhood, along with Israeli military activity in the Gaza Strip, have threatened to undermine the new peace talks.

The Palestinian delegation “introduced the issue of Har Homa and expressed our outrage,” said negotiator Saeb Erekat.

No mention of the rocket attacks until the fifteenth paragraph of the story, and not a word about them in the lede.

But the AP editors must have decided they really need to mention the attack of the “crude, homemade” rockets, especially because someone got hurt. Later:

JERUSALEM—The highly anticipated renewal of peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians got off to a rocky start Wednesday, with the Palestinians criticizing Israel for a construction project planned in disputed east Jerusalem, and Israel complaining about continued rocket fire from the Gaza Strip.

The Palestinians have said the planned construction in the Har Homa neighborhood, along with Israeli military activity in the Gaza Strip, have threatened to undermine the new peace talks.

The Palestinian delegation “introduced the issue of Har Homa and expressed our outrage,” said negotiator Saeb Erekat.

Notice how the lede changes almost not at all. The rocket attacks stay unmentioned again until paragraph fourteen. The number of rockets has been upped to twenty, which indicates that the editors are, indeed, on top of the news—but that they are not willing to grant rocket attacks as high a priority as building houses on disputed (by the Palestinians) territory. The real threat to the peace talks? Not acts of war. Buildings. Not Palestinian terrorists. Israeli “settlers.” Not the PA. Israel. Always Israel.

It is a wonder that anyone in the world believes that Israel is at all in the right. Because it’s certain that the media never do.

Posted in AP Media Bias, Media Bias | Comments Off on The wire services: Working for the Palestinians

The lost art of self-defense

Israel seems to have forgotten how to defend herself.

The security cabinet announced Wednesday it would recommend the government refrain from launching a wide-scale operation in Gaza, opting instead to continue with targeted IDF operations.

The cabinet thinks the small operations are successful.

Data given to the cabinet revealed that the IDF has held 115 operations aimed at destroying terror infrastructure and Qassam cells in the Strip since the beginning of the year, and killed 260 Palestinian terrorists.

They are wrong.

Still, some 970 Qassam rockets and 1,200 mortar shells were fired from Gaza towards Israel since the beginning of 2007. Israel suffered five related casualties – three IDF soldiers and two civilians.

Eighteen more rockets were launched today.

A Qassam barrage hit the western Negev Wednesday, as Palestinians fired 18 Qassam rockets at Sderot. One girl was lightly wounded in the leg by shrapnel, and several other people suffered shock.

The Palestinians are bragging, and why shouldn’t they? Their tactics are working. They murdered Israelis in Gaza, tried to murder Israelis from Gaza, and succeeded in driving out all Israelis from Gaza—from where they now launch attacks that wound and murder Israelis. And the Israelis are in utter denial about their ability to stop these attacks.

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni briefed the cabinet on the political efforts made in regards to the situation in Gaza. The world, said Livni, understands Israel’s need to defend itself against terror.

Really? Tell that to the New York Times editors.

In the meantime, the Israeli generals that aren’t running for office and haven’t served in office, and are only concerned with protecting Israel, and not their reputations, say that there’s no way the current situation can continue.

The current situation in Gaza cannot continue, and ongoing Qassam attacks on Israel may force the IDF to launch a large-scale operation in the Strip, IDF Chief of Staff Lit.-Gen. Gabi Ashkenazi said Wednesday.

“You cannot defeat a terror organization without eventually taking control of the territory,” he said, “the only reason we have been successful in Judea and Samaria is because we control the area.”

Speaking at a conference hosted by the Institute for National Security Studies at the Tel Aviv University, Ashkenazi said that while the current limited army operations in Gaza impair the capabilities of terror organizations, they would never completely curb all attacks against Israel.

Funny how the generals in the trenches keep saying this, and the politicians keep on saying something else. It’s almost as if the politicians care more about their image than about their people’s safety. But no. That can’t be.

One final thought: When Israel went on the offensive against Hamas, and targeted their leadership, killing most of it, the Hamas suicide attacks ended. Why the current leadership seems to think that same tactic won’t work now is beyond me.

Posted in Gaza, Terrorism | Comments Off on The lost art of self-defense

The peace talks in “discord”—because of Israel, mostly

The world media spins against Israel yet again. And of course, here’s how it works. A barrage of rockets into Israel on the morning of the peace talks comes fifteen paragraphs into the main AP story released a few minutes ago. That’s right. It doesn’t come into the lede at all. It comes into the story 12 paragraphs in in the earlier version, which had the strange headline “Israel, Palestinians launch peace talks in discord” (now turned into “Israeli-Palestinian Peace Talks Resume”

And here are paragraphs eleven and twelve of that strangely-headlined Reuters story:

Israel regularly launches raids into the Gaza Strip to try to stop militants firing rockets and mortar bombs into southern Israel. Olmert said late on Tuesday the Jewish state would “not stop” until it removed the rocket threat.

The militant group Islamic Jihad said it fired 14 rockets into Israel on Wednesday and vowed to keep up attacks. An army spokeswoman said at least 16 rockets and mortars were fired. There were no reports of casualties in southern Israel.

I say strange, because apparently the discord is all caused by this:

Palestinians said on Wednesday they had demanded a halt to Israeli plans to build on occupied land when negotiators launched peace talks aimed at reaching a deal on Palestinian statehood by the end of 2008.

[…] Wednesday’s talks, which lasted for about 90 minutes, went ahead despite calls by some Palestinians for a boycott over Israeli plans to build new houses on occupied land in the Jerusalem area. Palestinian leaders decided to attend the talks but to focus on pressing Israel to freeze settlement building.

The first half of the article is all about Har Homa. The media has learned its job well. Its job, of course, is to push the Palestinian agenda and ignore the deaths and injuries of Israelis.

And watch this comparison of “complaints.”

Discussing Wednesday’s talks, an Israeli official confirmed the Palestinians complained about Har Homa, Jewish settlement construction in the West Bank and Israeli military activity in Gaza.

“We really wanted to see it as a procedural meeting in good spirit … They created a tense atmosphere,” the official said, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to discuss the meeting with the media.

The official said Israel complained about ongoing Palestinian rocket fire from the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip. Early Wednesday, Palestinian militants fired 16 homemade rockets toward Israel, causing minor damage and lightly wounding one woman, Israeli officials said.

The barrage came hours after Israeli forces ended a broad incursion into the coastal strip that killed six militants and left a wide swath of damage in its wake.

You see? Israel is building new homes, and that’s harming the peace talks. The Palestinians are wounding and attempting to murder Israelis, and that’s harming the peace talks. Same thing, right?

It is in the eyes of the rest of the world, apparently.

Really, I know I’ve written this at least a thousand times before, but I cannot believe how the world utterly ignores the terrorism against Israel, and focuses instead on the “injustice” of the Palestinians. You know what the Palestinians need to do? Suck. It. Up.

But they never will, because the world keeps on handing them money and refusing to make them responsible for ending the incitement, terror, and murder that they’ve been doing for the past sixty years. The peace talks? Oh, they’re failing because Israel refuses to submit to the will of Fatah (and Hamas and PIJ and all the rest).

What time is it? That’s right, folks. It’s Israeli Double Standard Time. Only on a day of the week that ends with a “y.”

Posted in AP Media Bias, Israeli Double Standard Time, Media Bias | Comments Off on The peace talks in “discord”—because of Israel, mostly

Syria’s quid pro quo for Annapolis

Here’s what the Dorktator took away as a lesson for his sending a representative to Annapolis:

A car bomb attack killed one of Lebanon’s top generals and at least two other people Wednesday, the military and state media said, putting even more pressure on the country’s delicate political situation.

The target of the attack, Brig. Gen. Francois Hajj, a top Maronite Catholic in the command, was considered a leading candidate to succeed the head of the military, Gen. Michel Suleiman, if Suleiman is elected president.

Hajj, 55, also led a major military campaign against Islamic militants over the summer.

The lesson is clear: Syria can murder as many Christian politicians in Lebanon as their murderous regime wishes to, and the world will not punish them in any way. Lebanon is on the verge of being returned to Syrian client-state rule, and the world stands by and penalizes Israel for building houses in Jerusalem suburbs.

So, how’s that UN investigation going? The one into the death of Rafik Hariri? Oh, that’s right. Nothing’s gone in since the summer. For some reason, the investigation has been back-burnered.

These are the wages of terrorism. And terrorism, it pays off. Just ask Hezbollah, Hamas, PIJ, and especially, the Palestinian Authority.

Posted in Lebanon, Syria, Terrorism | 3 Comments

Familar unproductive editorial

The editors of the NYT are all for Starting the peace process

Israelis and Palestinians are supposed to begin serious negotiations tomorrow after last month’s long-on-optics, short-on-specifics Annapolis peace meeting. Despite all the smiles and handshakes, both sides went home and fell back into some familiar, counterproductive patterns.

And what might those “familiar. counterproductive patterns” be?

Days after the American-led conference prepared the ground for the first serious peace talks in seven years, Israel announced that it would be adding 307 new homes to a settlement south of East Jerusalem, a violation of the spirit of Israel’s commitments.

A “violation of the spirit?”

And on the other side?

The government-run Palestinian Authority TV also clearly hasn’t gotten the post-Annapolis message: broadcasting a map of the region soon after the meeting that pointedly erased Israel.Important Arab states were invited to Annapolis so that they could bolster Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas as he confronts politically difficult choices. Saudi Arabia and Egypt, however, did Mr. Abbas no favors last week, arranging coveted pilgrimages for Palestinians on a Hamas-approved list.

Let’s be clear, these are no “violations of the spirit.” These violations are to the very assumptions of the peace process. The “no Israel” graphic of course is a confirmation of the statements of “moderate” PA officials that Israel can’t be a Jewish state. The idea that a Jewish state can exist in the Middle East is not accepted by Israel’s “peace partners.”

As far as Saudi Arabia and Egypt are concerned, I don’t know that they’re not doing Mr. Abbas any favors. He himself seems to be on the same page as Hamas.

Besides we’ve been down this road before.

‘Clinton said Israel compromised more than the Palestinians, but this is not accurate,” Helmi Barakat, a political analyst based in Washington, said in a Jezeera interview. ”According to international law, Jerusalem is occupied land and I do not believe the Arabs should be expected to compromise or give up their sovereignty over Jerusalem.”During the last few days, a number of Arab leaders like Crown Prince Abdullah of Saudia Arabia and President Mubarak have joined with Mr. Arafat’s domestic opponents in Islamic militant movements to weigh in on the issue. They all but threatened Mr. Arafat with political excommunication if he accepted Prime Minister Ehud Barak’s proposals for administrative control over parts of the city and access to — but not sovereignty over — the major Muslim sites.

Experts said, however, that Mr. Arafat did not need reminders.

”Arafat knew beforehand that any compromise on Jerusalem would be the end of Arafat,” said Tahsin Basheer, a former aide to Anwar Sadat, the Egyptian president who was the first Arab leader to make peace with Israel, in 1979.

And what must each side do to help the other?

They will have more luck if both can show their citizens that life can be better — today. Israel must work with the Palestinians to expedite passage through border checkpoints that are a constant source of Palestinian frustration. Mr. Abbas should order a review of Palestinian textbooks and order his aides to curb rhetoric that Israelis say incite terrorism.

Israel must take risks with its security and the Palestinians must watch what they say. (And note the weaselly qualifier “…that Israelis say incite …”)

How about something like this instead?
“The Palestinians must become serious about fighting terror so that Israel can expedite passage through checkpoints.”
or
“The Palestinians must use the massive amounts of foreign aid they are receiving to build a viable economic infrastructure instead of on luxury condos for their leaders.”
or
“The Palestinians ought to stop complaining about so-called Israeli “settlements.” If “settlements” (really “communities”) were the problem, there would be no more terror from Gaza.”
or
“The Palestinians must finally observe the commitments they started making back in 1993 in order to show the Israeli people that they are finally serious about making peace”

Daled Amos has the impertinence to ask a pertinent question:

Ever notice that the only ones who seem to be successfully forced to do things to increase Abbas’ stature in the eyes of Palestinian Arabs is Israel?

The problem with the editorial is that the editors of the Times have fallen back into a familiar, unproductive pattern of equivalence.

Crossposted on Soccer Dad.

Posted in Israel, Israeli Double Standard Time, Media Bias | 1 Comment

Ehud Barak says…

According to an article from JP:

A large-scale operation in the Gaza Strip has dropped to the back burner in recent days after an assessment within the defense establishment found that the daily border raids the IDF has been conducting have had an effect on Hamas’s military capabilities, senior defense officials said Tuesday.

If you are ready to believe this crapola, here is more:

Defense Minister Ehud Barak said the operation had achieved “very important results” in the fight against the manufacture and firing of Kassam rockets and mortar shells. Speaking during a visit to a navy base in Haifa, Barak said that IDF operations like the one on Tuesday allowed Israelis to celebrate Hanukka and light candles in peace.

But hold the horses with the celebrations, here is some news for Barak:

As post-Annapolis talks were set to kick off around Wednesday noon, Palestinians in the Gaza Strip fired two barrages of Kassam rockets at the western Negev. One person was lightly wounded and two very lightly wounded; one of the rockets landed on a sidewalk in the middle of a main street in the city.

Several salvoes fired in the early morning hours amounted to a total of 17 rockets fired in a space of less than two hours.

This immediately after the operation that “achieved very important results”…

Update: and more government-issue crap:

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert vowed on Tuesday to remove the threat of Qassam rockets from the southern part of the country.

Yeah… like we keep hearing for the last 7 years.

Cross-posted on SimplyJews.

Posted in Gaza, Israel, Politics | 1 Comment

A Hanukkah sermon

This sermon was written by Rabbi I.B. Koller, Rabbi Emeritus of Congregation B’nai Israel, Charleston, W.Va., and Rabbi Victor H. Urecki of B’nai Jacob Synagogue in Charleston, W. Va. I’ve been given permission to reprint their sermon. I think it’s fitting for the last night of Chanukah.

There is always a good reason for why Jews have the customs we have as a religion. At the same time, however, there is almost always a real reason for the customs we have as well. And when it comes to the dreidel and the latke, two particular objects of Chanukah we all know so well, the good reasons are not real and the real reasons are not good!

Next to the menorah, the shofar, and the Torah, the dreidel is perhaps the best known Jewish object. Here is what we do know about the dreidel. It is a four sided top with the Hebrew letters nun, gimel, hey, and shin. When you put the letters together, they form an acronym that stands for the phrase: “Nes Gadol Haya Sham” or “A great miracle happened there”. On Chanukah, it is customary to play a little gambling game using this top to celebrate this joyous holiday.

But why do Jews play dreidel? In other words, where does the dreidel come from? When did it start and why? Did Judah Maccabee start the tradition? Was it a custom created by the rabbis of the Talmud? If so, why a top and why gambling?

So here is the good reason for why we play dreidel, the reason we always hear. Dreidel was created a long time ago out of a need to be able to teach and pass on our faith when it had to be passed on in secret. During Roman times, when the study of Torah was outlawed, Jews had to find ways to fool the authorities and teach our faith when it was dangerous to do so. Thus, Jews created dreidel and other types of innocent games that could be played without arousing suspicion from the authorities. Dreidel conveyed the meaning and message of the holiday and allowed the story of Chanukah to be told without fear of discovery. Good reason.

Unfortunately, it is not the real reason. In fact, the dreidel originally had nothing to do with Chanukah and actually had more to do with the Christmas season!

Here is the real reason we play dreydl. In the winter (around Christmas time) in England and Ireland, a popular game called totum or teetotum was created. Totum was a game that started in the 1500’s to pass the time during the long winter season. Totum was a four sided top used for gambling with four letters – T (take all), H (take half), P (put down) and N (get nothing). In Eastern Europe, a similar game grew out of this totum and German letters were added to this pastime: – N (Nicht/ Nothing), G (Ganz/All), H (Halb/ Half), S (Shtel-in/ Put In). In Germany, the game was called “trundle” and when Jews started playing it, they put Hebrew letters on it and called it in Yiddish “varfl” ( to thrown in) or a “dreidel” (to spin).

So dreidel has its origins in England around Christmas time and later in Germany. Jews, therefore, who won’t buy or use German products or use anything associated with Christmas will have to rethink playing dreydl this year!

Oh, and don’t delve too deeply into the history of the latke, either. If you take some measure of pride in that Jewish delicacy, you will likely lose your appetite for it. Here, too, while the good reason is that the latke was created by Jews to celebrate the miracle of the “oil” (since the potato pancake is fried in oil), it actually didn’t start with us. The “latke” was actually a popular winter dish common throughout much of Poland centuries before Jews even got there. We took it and grafted it into our culture as well. Like the dreidel, the latke is not Biblical, Talmudic or even Jewish. It is no more Jewish than a hamburger.

(And don’t even ask me to tell you about Chanukah money or “Gelt”. I’m sorry to say that it, too, originally had nothing to do with Chanukah.)

Now, why am I doing this to our Chanukah traditions? Because I think this teaches us something very important about Judaism and Jewish survival.

Chanukah celebrates the story of the Jewish people rising up against those who would wanted to purge us of our heritage. It is the story of the Syrian-Greeks, in the year 165 B.C.E., defiling our Temple, trampling our religious way of life and demanding that we assimilate and become Hellenists. They wanted us to give up our identity and our religion.

You might think it ironic, therefore, that on this very holiday which celebrates victory over assimilation, that we play the dreidel game and eat latkes which are perfect examples of assimilation. After all, are we not using a game that was popularized by Christians and eating a delicacy from a culture that was not our own?

But my point is that Jews have survived because our people have been adept at making a distinction between assimilation and acculturation. Assimilation is the cultural absorption of a community into the main cultural body. Acculturation is adapting to new and different cultures and surroundings, being influenced but not swallowed up by those cultures. Acculturation is the only way to survive as a minority.

Jews have always had to battle to survive as a people. Christians, with nearly two billion followers, do not worry about their survival, nor do a billion Muslims, but the tiny Jewish minority of just under 14 million worldwide have always been embattled. When we weren’t being persecuted, we had to find ways to keep ourselves distinct and avoid disappearance. When we weren’t fleeing for our lives, we had to answer: how can we survive as a people without assimilating?

And for the last two thousand years, the Jewish religion has been able to survive precisely because Jews have successfully acculturated to society, adapting our heritage and faith to our surroundings. We like to think of Jews surviving because we were stubborn and refused to adapt to the surrounding cultures. Just the opposite! The truth of the matter is we successfully found ways to take aspects of every society we lived in and incorporate them into our own practices.

That is the meaning of dreidel, latke and a whole host of customs and tradition we do to this day. They were never part of the Torah, the Talmud or even the Codes of Jewish Law. They were traditions of the societies we lived in; we adopted them and adapted them into our world to be used to keep our faith and our people alive. We took the totum and made it a dreidel. That is not assimilation; that is acculturation and there is nothing wrong with that. Acculturation is the only way a minority can survive.

Think I am wrong? Look at how Jews took the German language, added Hebrew letters and created Yiddish; we also took Spanish, added Hebrew and created Ladino. Jews in Middle Eastern cultures created a more Eastern form of Jewish expression and Jews in Europe created a more Western influenced faith, from the foods we ate to the language we spoke to the prayers we recited. The religious “core” always stayed the same but the “trappings” changed to conform to the societies they were in.

The very key to our survival is found in the dreidel and the latke. The Jew didn’t assimilate, nor did he drop his heritage, but acculturated to the society he was in and found new ways to practice the faith of his ancestors. When faced with the challenge of survival, the Jew always acculturated as a way of maintaining his identity.

Look at what has happened to Chanukah in America, from the decorations that we have added as a result of Christmas to fancy menorahs that are more closely related to the American experience than anything seen by Judah Maccabee and his warriors. Purists may mortified by what they are seeing but I am not. I think it is the ongoing acculturation of our Jewish community, maintaining our cultural identity in a society that calls us to fully assimilate. Isolation is not an option and assimilation is cultural suicide; acculturation is how a people survives.

Acculturation is what Jews have done for centuries, from eating a Polish Potato Pancake and making it a Chanukah tradition, to taking a popular Christmas-time toy called totum and making a game that tells the story of Chanukah.

That’s the way we survive as a people!

Posted in Holidays, Jews, Religion | 9 Comments