Proof of life from Gilad Shalit

Color me shocked. I thought he was dead, and frankly, still think he may be. I don’t trust Hamas at all. But Hamas released a tape by Gilad Shalit.

An Israeli soldier captured a year ago by militants from Gaza asked for medical treatment and urged Israel to release Palestinian prisoners, in an audio tape posted on the Internet on Monday.

Except for a handwritten letter to his parents in September, there had been no sign of life from Gilad Shalit since the tank gunner was spirited into the Gaza Strip by gunmen who tunneled across the border into Israel on June 25, 2006.

“I have been in prison for an entire year and my health is deteriorating. I need lengthy hospitalization,” Shalit, speaking in Hebrew, said on the tape.

“I regret the lack of interest of the Israeli government and military in my case and their failure to meet the demands.”

Shalit’s father, speaking to Israeli television, confirmed the voice was that of his son, a conscript now aged 20. He was promoted to sergeant from corporal while in captivity.

Hamas, one of three militant groups that claimed responsibility for the joint operation in which Shalit was seized, said earlier it would release the tape to mark the first anniversary of his capture.

And let us point out once again that Hamas is the supposed democratically-elected government of the Palestinians, and so the democratically-elected government of the Palestinians, with whom former president Jimmy Carter thinks the world should negotiate, are acting like the band of criminals and murderers they are, trying to extort concessions from Israel, instead of trying to, say, negotiate in good faith, like real governments do. But Hamas has never been a real government. Real governments don’t murder the opposition party.

By the way, the above is from Reuters, who call the attackon Shalit “a cross-border raid.” So does the AP.

Shalit was captured on June 25, 2006, in a cross-border raid by militants from Hamas and two allied groups who tunneled into Israel from the Gaza Strip. Negotiations for his release, mediated by Egypt, have repeatedly broken down and been complicated since Hamas took control of Gaza two weeks ago.

Let’s take a look at what the AP wrote a year ago about that “cross-border raid.”

KIBBUTZ KEREM SHALOM, Israel Jun 25, 2006 (AP)— Palestinian militants from the Gaza Strip infiltrated Israel through a tunnel early Sunday, lobbing grenades and bombs at a military outpost and killing two Israeli soldiers and seizing a third.

The ruling Hamas group said its fighters participated in the attack, calling it an act of revenge for Israel’s recent killing of militant leaders and civilians. Militants said three of their fighters were killed in a gunbattle with soldiers.

[…] Militants crossed under Israel’s border fence with Gaza through a tunnel and lobbed bombs and grenades at an Israeli tank and an armored personnel carrier at the border post, the military said. Simultaneously, anti-tank missiles were fired at both vehicles from inside Gaza, the army said.

Two other militants, meanwhile, attacked a 25-yard high observation post with assault rifles, touching off a gunbattle with soldiers in which several militants were killed, the military said.

Some little raid, huh?

And in a man-bites-dog angle, B’tselem has accused someone other than Israel of war crimes:

Meanwhile, the Israeli human rights group B’Tselem accused the militants holding Shalit of war crimes.

“International humanitarian law absolutely prohibits taking and holding a person by force in order to compel the enemy to meet certain demands, while threatening to harm or kill the person if the demands are not met,” the group said. “Furthermore, hostage-taking is considered a war crime.”

Someone check the sky for flying pigs.

This entry was posted in Hamas, Israel, Media Bias. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Proof of life from Gilad Shalit

  1. ZZ says:

    Poor kid. I pray he and his family can bear this ordeal and that he will escape safelty.

  2. Joel says:

    Cut off water, electricity, power and food supplies to Gaza. However Goofball Olmert will do nothing to upset his boyfriend “Abu Mazen”.

  3. ZZ says:

    I don’t think that would work Joel. I’m pretty sure that the terrorists don’t care how much the civilian population suffers.

  4. yitz says:

    The only proof we have so far is that HE WAS ALIVE when this was made, if indeed it was him, as his parents seem to be confirming. We don’t know when the tape was made. It’s clear that he was under duress in what he said as well (asking for release of terrorists, etc.) Still, let us pray that he is reunited with his family soon, without us having to release terrorists to do more of their despicable “work.”

  5. John Doe says:

    For Christ sake Meryl and Yitz, Gilad Shalit IS ALIVE!!!!! Hamas has given Israel the proof of life they wanted. Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev are probably dead though. :( I hope I’m wrong.

  6. John, there is actually no real proof that tape was made recently, or that Gilad is alive. It is only audio, not video. No one outside of the terrorists holding him has seen him.

    When the Red Cross or someone who is not a terrorist sees Gilad, I will believe he’s truly still alive. Until then, I have my doubts.

Comments are closed.