via memeorandum
Coming hot on the heels of reports of dissension in Hezbollah comes the news that not every Palestinian necessarily wishes to live under the PA’s rule.
Mark Mackinnon of the Globe and Mail reports that Some Palestinians prefer life in Israel
Those who live in the neighbourhoods Mr. Olmert spoke of handing over are nonetheless worried that Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas, who is seen as weak and desperate for an achievement after losing control of the Gaza Strip to the Islamist Hamas movement, will accept the offer. They dislike the idea of their neighbourhoods, which are generally more prosperous than other parts of the West Bank, being absorbed into the chaotic Palestinian territories.Mr. Gheit, with two posters of “the martyr Saddam Hussein” hanging over his cash register, can hardly be called an admirer of the Jewish state. But he says that an already difficult life would get worse if those living in Ras Hamis and the adjoining Shuafat refugee camp were suddenly no longer able to work in Israel, or use its publicly funded health system.
The 53-year-old said he’d be happy to one day live in a properly independent Palestinian state, but not one that looks anything like the corruption-racked and violence-prone areas that are split between the warring Hamas and Fatah factions. “I don’t believe in these factions. I only believe in putting bread on the table for my children. I fight only for them. At least in Israel, there’s law.”
This is not a new phenomenon. In 2000 when it was thought that PM Barak and Arafat would still work out a deal that would cede Jerusalem neighborhoods to the PA, the Palestinians living in those areas started applying for Israeli citizenship. This prompted the Mufti of Jerusalem to issue a fatwa against applying.
Israeli media reports today said the number of applications for citizenship had doubled in the past year to more than one-hundred and eighty. An Israeli interior ministry spokeswoman said that twelve-hundred Palestinians from east Jerusalem had been granted citizenship since it was captured by Israel in 1967.
Daniel Pipes reported at the time:
When Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak’s diplomacy raised the prospect, in mid-2000, of some Arab-majority parts of Jerusalem being transferred to the PA, a Palestinian Arab social worker found that “an overwhelming majority” of Jerusalem’s 200,000 Arabs chose to remain under Israeli control. A member of the Palestinian National Council, Fadal Tahabub, specified that 70% preferred Israeli sovereignty. Another politician, Husam Watad, described people as “in a panic” at the prospect of finding themselves under PA rule.
And it wasn’t just limited to Jerusalem:
In the Galilee Triangle, a Palestinian-majority area in the north of the country, just 30% of the Arab population agreed to some of the Galilee Triangle being annexed to a future Palestinian state, according to a May 2001 survey, meaning that a large majority preferred it to remain in Israel. By February 2004, when the Sharon government released a trial balloon about giving the PA control over the Galilee Triangle, the Haifa-based Arab Center for Applied Social Research found the number had jumped to 90%. And 73% of Triangle Arabs said they would use violence to prevent changes in the border.
A Palestinian state sounds great hypothetically. Except to many for whom living in it would mean a lower standard of living.
See also Melanie Phillips, Boker Tov Boulder, To the moon.
Crossposted on Soccer Dad.
IIRC, Arabs in Port Suez and Port Said demonstrated against the corruption and incompetence of Egyptian authorities with signs saying “The Israelis were better than you.”
They always miss us when we’re gone.
chsw
Yes, I saw that Globe and Mail article, too. In all fairness, however, it should be pointed out that that the shopkeeper was not really pro-Israel. [The article mentions that he had posters in his shop hailing Saddam Hussein as a martyr.] He just doesn’t want to be ruled by the P.A. as long as it remains corrupt and ineffectual. However, he would prefer to live in an independent Palestine. The article says that he and other Arabs living in Israel prefer to live under a rule of law and social benefits in the meantime, even if they might not like the Israeli government. It’s a question of a lesser of evils for the time being.
It should also be pointed out that, although there were indeed figures a few years ago showing a rather high level of patriotism toward Israel among Israeli Arabs, those figures dropped substantially in the wake of last year’s Lebanon war.
Here’s a link on that subject:
http://tinyurl.com/2rhaur
As long as Gheit and his fellow Arabs look on thugs like Saddam Hussein as great men and martyrs, so long will he and all the other Arabs be stuck with corrupt and incompetent Arab governments, whether by the PA, or Hamas, or any other. The only chance the Arabs have for halfway decent self-government is going to be by joining in the trend now proceeding in Iraq, and maintaining it rather than letting the nihilistic death cultists return them to tyrannies like Saddam’s. The jury is still out on that, and will be for some time. If the Arabs blow the chance that the Coalition, especially the US Army and Marine Corps, have given them by the expenditure of blood and treasure, they will never get another chance at liberty and prosperity.